Skip to main content
AC Machinery
Plasma or fiber laser: what does each foot of cut cost?
Resources

Plasma or fiber laser: what does each foot of cut cost?

In a worked example from our laser cutting cost analysis, a 20 kW fiber laser cut mild steel for less per foot than plasma at every one of ten thicknesses, from 10 gauge to 1-1/2 inch. Most of the difference is not gas. It is labour.

Adam BenderPresident, AC Machinery

In a worked example from our laser cutting cost analysis, a 20 kW fiber laser cut mild steel for less per foot than plasma at every one of ten thicknesses, from 10 gauge to 1-1/2 inch. At 10 gauge it cost about $0.013 a foot against $0.106 on plasma. A 12 kW laser was cheaper up to 3/4 inch, then cost more than plasma from 1 inch up, where it also cut more slowly. Most of the difference is not gas. It is labour: the laser cuts the same footage in a fraction of the hours.

Where do these numbers come from?

We prepared this example with our cost analysis tool, the same one we use to prepare a report for a shop that is weighing a fiber laser against its plasma. The example shop is fictional, but the method is the one we use with real customers. It starts from the plasma's known operating costs and the shop's real production, and every input is printed so the shop can check it.

The example shop cuts mild steel on one plasma, two 8-hour shifts a day, six days a week, 50 weeks a year. Its mix runs from 10 gauge to 1-1/2 inch and adds up to 794,724 feet of cut a year. Every laser is costed on exactly those feet.

Input in the examplePlasmaFiber laser
Share of each clock hour spent cutting35% arc-on75% beam-on
Operator, burdened ($35.00 wage plus $30.00 payroll burden)$65.00 an hour$65.00 an hour
Extra labour or parts cleaning+50% on plasma labour hoursnone
Gas supplyoxygen and nitrogen in 16-packs, air from a compressoroxygen in packs, nitrogen or N2/O2 mix from a nitrogen generator, air from a compressor
Electricity$0.16 per kWh$0.16 per kWh (40% wall-plug efficiency)
Dust collector, while cutting12.7 kW6.3 kW
Consumables15% discount applied

Gas prices are typical Ontario rates for each supply method. The laser and the plasma each buy their gas the way a shop running that machine usually does.

What does a foot of cut cost on plasma and on a fiber laser?

These figures count gas, consumables, electricity (dust collector included) and the operator while the machine is cutting. They do not include the machine itself.

Mild steelPlasma12 kW laser20 kW laser30 kW laser
10 ga (3.6 mm)$0.106$0.016$0.013$0.012
3/16" (4.8 mm)$0.103$0.022$0.017$0.013
1/4" (6.4 mm)$0.145$0.026$0.018$0.015
3/8" (9.5 mm)$0.147$0.058$0.046$0.027
1/2" (12.7 mm)$0.202$0.120$0.055$0.033
5/8" (15.9 mm)$0.199$0.137$0.092$0.053
3/4" (19.1 mm)$0.245$0.156$0.133$0.078
1" (25.4 mm)$0.251$0.431$0.157$0.163
1-1/4" (31.8 mm)$0.345$0.652$0.171$0.178
1-1/2" (38.1 mm)$0.468$1.026$0.356$0.253

Cost per linear foot, Canadian dollars, from the worked example.

On thin and medium plate the laser cuts with nitrogen or an N2/O2 mix. On thicker plate it switches to oxygen, because the tool picks the lowest-cost gas that still keeps the best edge at each thickness. The 12 kW switches to oxygen from 1/2 inch, the 20 kW from 3/4 inch and the 30 kW from 1 inch. The 12 kW stays cheaper than plasma to 3/4 inch, but at 1 inch it cuts on oxygen at 35 inches a minute, where the plasma runs at 75.

How fast does each machine cut?

Mild steelPlasma12 kW20 kW30 kWFastest laser vs plasma
10 ga1459651,1811,2808.8×
3/16"1556899451,1817.6×
1/4"1105919061,0839.8×
3/8"1102663545915.4×
1/2"801262954926.2×
5/8"801101773254.1×
3/4"65981162363.6×
1"7535100981.3×
1-1/4"652493931.4×
1-1/2"481645671.4×

Inches per minute. Plasma at the amperage that suits each thickness (50 A at 10 gauge up to 400 A at 1-1/4 and 1-1/2 inch).

Speed is the whole story on thin material. At 1/4 inch the fastest laser cuts nearly ten times faster than the plasma. At 1 inch the fastest laser is only about a third faster.

Why does labour, not gas, decide the cost?

The per-foot table only counts the operator while the machine is cutting. A year in a real shop also pays for the time around the cut, and that is where the difference opens up.

A plasma torch in this example cuts for 35% of each clock hour. The rest of the hour the torch is not cutting. On top of that, the example adds 50% to the plasma's labour hours for extra labour or parts cleaning. The laser cuts for 75% of each hour, and it cuts faster. So the same 794,724 feet take very different amounts of time:

A year in the example shopPlasma12 kW laser20 kW laser30 kW laser
Operating hours4,800 h1,913 h862 h662 h
Labour (plasma includes extra labour)$468,000$124,352$56,020$43,012
Electricity$6,736$6,887$4,945$4,729
Dust collector$3,413$1,458$657$504
Gas$9,060$6,084$2,807$2,559
Consumables$13,284$2,495$947$714
Operating cost a year$500,493$141,276$65,375$51,518
Shifts a day needed2.00.80.40.3

Canadian dollars, before the machine's purchase price. One operator per machine.

Labour is $468,000 of the plasma's $500,493. Gas, consumables and electricity together are about 6% of it. A shop that compares the two machines on gas and consumables alone is comparing the smallest lines on the sheet.

The chain is simple. A slower cut means more cutting hours. A lower arc-on share turns each cutting hour into nearly three clock hours. Every one of those hours is paid at the burdened rate, and the 50% for extra labour or parts cleaning adds more. In this example that is the difference between two shifts a day and less than half a shift on the 20 kW or 30 kW for the same work.

Where does plasma still hold its own?

We supply both plasma cutting machines and fiber lasers, so we have no reason to tell you plasma is finished. In this example it is not.

  • Thick plate on a lower-power laser. From 1 inch up, the 12 kW costs more per foot than the plasma and cuts at half its speed or less. A shop whose work is mostly 1 inch and over, looking at a 12 kW, should look hard at that line of the table.
  • The margin narrows with thickness on every laser. At 1 inch the 20 kW is only about a third faster than the plasma, against about six times faster at 3/16 inch.
  • Thickness range. In this example the 12 kW cuts up to 1-1/2 inch, and the 20 kW and 30 kW up to 2 inch. How thick a fiber laser cuts mild steel sets out the range by power.

The answer depends on the mix. A shop cutting mostly thin and medium plate sees the largest difference. From 1 inch up, only the 20 kW and 30 kW beat the plasma on cost in this example, so a heavy-plate shop should compare those powers on its own thicknesses.

What changes the answer for your shop?

Every figure above follows from the inputs, so the inputs are where to start with your own shop.

  • Cost per foot does not depend on volume. It comes from cutting speed and the hourly costs: at twice the example's volume the yearly cost doubles and the cost per foot stays the same.
  • Your arc-on share matters more than almost anything else. If your plasma cuts for more of each hour than 35%, the yearly gap shrinks. If it cuts for less, the yearly gap grows.
  • Your labour rate and your parts cleaning move the yearly figure almost one for one, because labour is most of it.
  • Your thickness mix decides which laser power fits. The example shop's 1 inch work is 15% of its plasma's cutting time; a shop with more heavy plate gets a different answer.

How each line is worked out, so you can check it:

  • Cutting hours = feet at each thickness ÷ feet cut per hour at that thickness.
  • Operating hours = cutting hours ÷ beam-on 75% (plasma: ÷ arc-on 35%).
  • Labour = operating hours × $65.00 an hour; plasma labour × 1.5 for extra labour or parts cleaning.
  • Gas, consumables, electricity and the dust collector = cutting hours × their cost per cutting hour.

How far can you rely on these figures?

The cutting speeds and costs come from published laboratory cutting data. Real results vary with machine configuration, material quality, gas purity, nozzle condition and how well the machine is maintained. The analysis applies to the lasers we supply and optimize. It does not transfer to other brands of laser.

The same tool can compare one fiber laser power against another (for example, what moving from 6 kW to 20 kW is worth), and a CO2 laser against a fiber laser.

Send us your plasma's numbers

Send us what you cut on your plasma (thicknesses and the share of time at each), your shifts, and what you pay for labour, gas and consumables. We will prepare the same analysis for your shop and show which laser power, if any, makes sense for it. We are based in Cambridge, Ontario.

Ask for a laser cutting cost analysis

About Adam Bender

Adam spent roughly twenty years as a field technician servicing plasma and laser cutting machines before taking over AC Machinery. These notes come from that work.

Adam Bender on LinkedIn

FAQ

Common questions

Short answers to the questions we are asked most about this topic.

In our worked example, yes on most mild steel: a 20 kW laser cost less per foot than plasma at all ten thicknesses from 10 gauge to 1-1/2 inch. A 12 kW laser cost more than plasma from 1 inch up. The answer for your shop depends on your thicknesses, your labour and how much of each hour your plasma actually cuts.

In the example, between about $0.10 and $0.47 a foot on mild steel from 10 gauge to 1-1/2 inch, counting gas, consumables, electricity (dust collector included) and the operator while cutting. The yearly cost per foot is higher, because the operator is paid for the hours around the cut too.

It depends on the power. In the example, the 30 kW was faster than plasma at every thickness, but only by a third to two fifths from 1 inch up. The 20 kW was a third to two fifths faster at 1 and 1-1/4 inch, and slightly slower at 1-1/2 inch. The 12 kW was slower than plasma from 1 inch up.

No. These are operating costs. The purchase price of the laser comes on top.